Rohit's Realm

// rohitsrealm.com / archive / 2005 / 03 / 20 / reveling-in-irrelevance

March 20, 2005

Reveling in Irrelevance

Although the seemingly incredulous and often times, surreal, events of the past four years have completely succeeded in leaving me in a perpetual state of disbelief, disillusion, and discombobulation, current events seem to only exacerbate my dark disenchantment with the political system of this country and those who perpetuate it. While the 2004 election brought shock, and the recent developments regarding evolution in schools, outrage, tonight's news regarding the passage of Congressional legislation supporting Terri Schiavo's right to live simply makes me wonder whether I've been watching a terrible movie for the last few years - a movie that just won't end and keeps getting worse.

I had been following the drama of the Schiavo case off and on for the past few years since it leapt onto the national stage, but never really understood why it had gained such prominence. For me, the case seemed undeniably tragic, but not particularly complex from a legal standpoint. Given the testimony of several court-appointed doctors who agreed that Schiavo had lost cognitive function and persisted solely in a vegetative state, as well as the husband's status as legal guardian, the decision to remove the feeding tube keeping her alive seemed almost self-evident. Yet, month after month, and year after year, new obstacles and legal manueverings seemed to stagnate an issue that had already lingered on entirely too long.

The intervention of the right to life groups claiming to know Schiavo's wishes when medical experts could not was irritating and reminiscent of all the posturing common to situations involving abortion cases. The emergence of every nutjob from crazed fundamentalist groups only worsened a situation already ridden in tragedy, by allowing the shameless exploitation by soulless politicians seeking to rally a conservative constituency. When the Florida legislature intervened in October of 2003, I was shocked that it was allowed to progress, considering how ridiculous it seemed for the legislature to pass a law pertaining to only one person and one specific circumstance. The intervention by Congress, more than a year later, after the Florida legislature was rebuked, seems equally ridiculous, but infinitely more disconcerting, considering the precedence of such an action.

I don't know what's more sad - that the Republicans are exploiting this situation so thoroughly and unabashedly or that the Democrats are sitting back like pansies, doing nothing, probably fearing backlash from the moral majority. What makes the situation even more dismaying is that while Congress, in the past weeks, hasn't been able address any major issue facing the nation or even figure out a budget, did manage to return after leaving for Easter recess explicitly to vote on this particular bill. It's always great to know that our illustrious representatives have their priorities straight!

I'm not sure how much more of this type of nonsense I can handle; it might be time to join my MTV-watching, collar-popping friends in political ignorance and apathy. Atleast then I won't have to be depressed everytime I read the news.

Comments

Some reasons not to lose faith:

The CBS News Poll conducted yesterday found a majority supported the removal of the feeding tube (66%) and further, an overwhelming 82% believed that Congress and the White House should have stayed out of the matter, independent of political affiliation and beliefs.

Also notable is the fact that Congressional job approval has dropped to the lowest its been since 1997, at 34%, and President Bush's approval has dropped to 43%, down from 49% in February 2005.

This is one of the first times in several years I've read the news and actually felt content. Guess the uneasy feeling I had about this case with regards to unwarranted government attention was felt by most Americans! From the looks of it, Frist, DeLay, and company are in for some trouble. Seems like they forgot that while pandering to their conservative base, they shouldn't alienate the rest of America.

This saga just won't end! Today, the full 11th Circuit Court of Appeals rejected yet another appeal. One of the judges on the panel, a conservative Republican, wrote:

When the fervor of political passions moves the executive and legislative branches to act in ways inimical to basic constitutional principles, it is the duty of the judiciary to intervene. If sacrifices to the independence of the judiciary are permitted today, precedent is established for the constitutional transgressions of tomorrow.

I couldn't have put it better myself! I just wish all these crazed fundamentalists would let this issue rest!

Well at least the parents are making the most of it:

http://www.boingboing.net/2005/03/31/schiavo_parents_to_s.html

Add Comment


 


 


 


 


* required field

E-mail addresses will never be displayed. The following HTML tags are allowed:
a abbr acronym address big blockquote br cite del em li ol p pre q small strong sub sup ul